There’s something simple behind Trump’s 20-point plan for Gaza—we now have a colony on the Mediterranean. It is a state containing Palestinians without being a Palestinian state. Since we’re in charge it’s ours, even if we counting on others to pay for it or somehow keep the peace.

It’s not the first colony we’ve had recently.  There was also Afghanistan and to a lesser extent Iraq.  Colonies can seem rational—even benevolent—at the start, but it doesn’t tend to work out that way.  So we have to hope this one works better.

But that’s getting too far ahead.  What is there to say about the plan?  First, there is no denying that it is a lot better than continuing the war.  This has always been a particularly terrible affair, because in this horrible mess both sides wanted to kill as many Palestinians as possible.  For Netanyahu, the prime objective has been to kill enough of the enemy so that the Israeli population would forget that he was responsible for the success of the October 7 attacks.  For Hamas, the main point was to prevent any kind of Israeli-arab cooperation and to provoke an Israeli counterattack that would demonstrate the evils of Israel to the wider world.  Before his death Sinwar gloated to his boss in Qatar about the number of Palestinian dead he had achieved for the cause. What world this is!

With the peace comes the colonial bureaucracy.  The Palestinians aren’t running anything, because the Israelis don’t trust them to even the slightest degree.  In Netanyahu’s UN speech the Palestinians were described in every instance as unrepentant, vicious terrorists.  The plan has a lot of talk about how Gaza will be purged of Hamas, and there will be a whole new body to keep the peace—once it is ready.  Until then (whenever that is) the Israeli army will need to do that job.  There is a longer-term objective of maybe someday a Palestinian state once Palestinians can somehow be trusted to live in peace with Israelis.  Netanyahu has been explicit about when that is—never.

In the interim it’s not clear what is going to happen, except hopefully relief for Palestinians (an expensive proposition) and the encouragement of business investment.  There is no guarantee how much business investment will be aimed at the well-being of Palestinians.  Anything done for the Palestinians will come under US control and with arab or even Israeli investment.  On the face of it, this sounds like a bunch of fancy hotels and a massive complex of cheap apartment buildings to serve them.  I’m also a little worried about who else might be coming as immigrants, but which may or may not be an issue.  It’s hard to guess how peaceful this is going to be.  The horrors of the past two years are such that one can’t imagine there won’t be resentment.  The ideas of Hamas will be harder to exorcize than the known Hamas fighters. And we can’t know what will happen with the released arab prisoners.

So it’s great that the war is going to end.  At least to start with this particular plan seems dictated by the needs of Israeli security combined with Trump’s fervor for real estate development. However, the first step will be meeting the immediate needs of the Palestinians for a peaceful, livable future.  That is already such a challenge that the rest is up for grabs.