World Order and the EU Model

There are lots of arguments for and against world governance.  The negatives are easy:  there is no enforcement, there are any number of ways to cheat for advantages, rules are always going to reflect the interests of the countries with the power to dictate them.  Any rule gets in the way of our ability to work for our advantage.  What’s more, anything imposed worldwide is a straitjacket—there is no way to hide, no way to escape it.

However historically the opposite of order has been worse:  instability, imperialism, slavery, and war.  The post-World War II period has been far from perfect, but still a record period of prosperity and at least relative peace.  Furthermore we have a specific example of a corner of the world (Europe) that ended centuries of conflict by relinquishing power to an international body—the EU—that brought peace and prosperity (despite all those negatives). Humans have managed to graduate from small tribes to cities to nation states, so why not farther?

Much has been written on that subject, but what is undeniable is that peace and prosperity go together.  Why is it so hard, when we’ve seen examples of success? In fact there’s an answer but only if we ask the question right. The problem with a world order is not that it can’t be made to work—that’s what has been done.  It’s that there are too many forces that want it to fail.

Today’s USA is a case in point.  Trump rose to power with the slogan of “America First”—the idea that all problems were due to immigrants and foreigners taking advantage of us, so untrammeled American power was the highway to everyone’s success.  It was a great story—we know exactly what to do to get rich, and what’s more we can enjoy the pain we inflict on all the bad guys.  So the right vision for international relations is might makes right.  That’s the natural order of things, and of course we’ll win.

Two years later the problems are still around (or worse), billionaires and insiders are collecting benefits, and even the idea that we’re always on top is not so clear. We live in a complicated interconnected world, and however much we bluster about national self-sufficiency, we have no idea how to do it.  “Rare earths” are more the norm than the exception in a world with choke points everywhere.  After all the technological underpinning of a very large chunk of our current and future economy is at TSMC, 80 miles off the coast of China. (Their US production won’t change that.) What’s more the main target of all the tariffs and other economic weapons we’re rolling out is precisely the one country against whom we have essentially no defense! The Democratic successes in the recent election show that some part of the population now realizes the story was always a con, but the issue is how reliably that argument works.

Every nationalist movement tells that same story.   It appeals to something fundamentally tribal in the human makeup:  “My people aren’t like that.”  Get rid of the others, and all will be fine.  Humans may have managed to graduate to nation states, but the tendency to division and conflict remains.  (Thurber’s little storybook (The Last Flower) comes to mind.  “Liberators” as in the picture are the worst.)

So how do we get past this?  What’s different now is that we cannot continue to believe that the rest of the world simply doesn’t matter.  The dangers are worldwide, too pressing, and too great.  Let’s make a list.  I’d put nuclear weapons at the top—we’re encouraging nuclear proliferation at the same time that prohibitions on use of such weapons seem to be weakening in both Ukraine and Iran, and finally as we’ve embarked on new rounds of  an AI-based arms race.  Then there is climate change—where there is still no appreciation of the dangers of waiting, the Covid-demonstrated inadequacy of response to epidemic, and the still unclear consequences of AI itself.  A recent novel set in 2119 delivered a clear verdict on our times: the young people of that future world had no interest in history—why should they care about people whose craven negligence had produced world war and climate catastrophe!

The only way out is to start working on solvable problems.  The EU started with common trade rules for base products: coal and steel.  Economics is the necessary first step.  Trade relations come  before politics.  Unfortunately in this country there is whole false mythology on that subject:  “Bill Clinton let China in the WTO, and that lost 5 million jobs.” Clinton did let China in the WTO, but the President who lost all those jobs was George W. Bush. Bush had no interest in acting against China in the WTO and instead promoted offshoring of jobs, because that was what American business wanted.  Bush even removed buy-American rules for government purchases. Walmart was the smiling US face of “evil China”.  As a recent paper pointed out, the WTO continues to have an important role and is the single first place to start getting international relations right.  Our current tariff policy, by contrast, hurts us and our allies and has weakened our leverage with China to nothing.

Similarly we need to get back into the World Health Organization (where our absence puts us at risk) and we need to return to an active role in international efforts to address climate change.  As it is, our climate denial is bad for its own sake and contributes more to China’s industrial dominance every day (helped on by the Iran war).

None of this is enough to pull the world together to address all the dangers, but these activities are doable and start to address what it means to work together.  That’s what worked for the EU.  Anything more is beyond the scope of this piece.  But the dangers of nationalist divisions and conflict remain.  For that there are no silver bullets.  The best hope is progress toward global prosperity—which remains, despite all slogans to the contrary, in the interest of all.

The Failed Triumph of Privilege

A few weeks ago I did a piece on making democracy work.  It strikes me now that I need a broader context for this—about governance generally.

The point of departure for any such discussion is the role for the powers-that-be, the rich and powerful in society.  That group has built-in power by virtue of its economic clout, as well as a conviction that it is superior and ought to rule.  However it also has built-in limitations for such a role.  Generally speaking:

– It is uninterested in the well-being of the population (its inferiors).  On the contrary these are defenders of privilege.

– It wants to protect itself through monopolies, tariffs, corruption, and the like.

– It discounts the future in pursuit of immediate profit.

– It assumes all knowledge or issues outside its purview are worthless.

All of these sound familiar, but it is important to recognize they aren’t just for Trump. This is the overweening confidence of privilege.

For that reason one of the most fundamental problems of national governance is managing relations with the rich and powerful class.  It will always want to govern and must be kept healthy but in check—a difficult balancing act.  And the issue is not just for sake of the less fortunate.  The short-term and generally myopic focus mean that this group will not provide even for its own longer-term success.  Adam Smith himself understood all of that perfectly.

The prior piece on democracy was mostly about addressing the first point.  The other points are different, about institutional competence and recognition of the jobs that government must do.  That’s worth emphasizing—if government doesn’t address those points, the job won’t get done.  Government has to take responsibility for the success of the country.  The private sector will not do it.

Such work cannot happen without the institutional competence to get it done. That’s why it was an enormous step forward when this country created a civil service with agencies protected from politics.  The Supreme Court’s repudiation of agencies shows the danger we’re in.

Successful balancing delivered the huge success of this country.  We were technology innovators, looking for new ways to expand the economy.   We educated all our people to a degree unheard-of before.  We funded universities and pure research.  We strengthened our military and economic position through alliances.  (It is worth stating explicitly that NATO is and always was a vehicle to defend us—with multiple forces always under US command.)  We developed the interstate highway system and other internal infrastructure second to none.  We protected our health and resources. 

That successful role of government was established here following the recovery from the depression and then World War II.  No one then was arguing about the role for government.  And that attitude persisted through the postwar success.  At that time we were united as a middle class society with what we felt were common goals.

The widely-agreed turning point was the Reagan administration, when the powers-that-be realized that there was a path to a future where they could buy elections and win. It’s no accident that Reagan repealed the so-called “fairness doctrine” for TV political coverage, removing constraints on what money could buy as propaganda.  Plato (in his “Republic”) warned that democracy provides the tools for autocrats to seize power.  Democracy capture by oligarchy is a perpetual threat.  And here the US Constitution proved particularly fertile ground.

In the end the Supreme Court has been the “Achilles heel” of American democracy.  With undemocratic nominations and lifetime appointments it was only a matter of time (and luck) before the Court was  bought.  The Koch organization people devoted decades to that task.  The Citizens United decision essentially sealed the deal. Almost immediately it enabled elections to be bought and legislative districts gerrymandered.  The final stage came with the death of Ruth Bader Ginsberg, so that the Court had an unbeatable majority of members whose Koch-nurtured careers had prepared them for their roles. We have now reached the stage of historically unique (for the US) inequality—and diminished expectations for all .

Influence of money on politics is a given. It is present to a greater or lesser degree in particular issues and administrations. Capture of government by privilege is qualitatively different. There is no one left who needs convincing and effectively nothing standing in the way. So incomes on top can keep growing while fundamental needs remain unmet.

Trump is their vehicle.  He is erratic, narcissistic, and vicious, but he’s on board with the program.  And he’s a phenomenal salesman.  On voting he’s a virtuoso with the most basic of sales techniques:  when your product has a defect you tell the world your opponents have it.  Looking to steal an election and with no examples of fraudulent voting, he tells Republicans to “try and cheat like hell like they do”. And much of the country believes it.

With Citizens United the Court played a big role in Trump’s election, and since then it has awarded him extraordinary powers, even putting him above the law.  Calling Trump a populist confuses his carefully-tailored image with reality.  Think instead of Trump in his element at his recent celebratory dinner for Xi.  It’s not just Trump. We are living the triumph of privilege.

Democracy is inherently fragile.   The powers-that-be will always think they deserve to rule, and they know how to profit when they get it.  But as noted before, however much they celebrate—they are victims too.  For all the reasons we’ve discussed their win turns into a loss for everyone.  Let’s look at some of what we’ve got:

– Future compromised (research funding limited and politicized, huge deficit in good times)

– Government competence undermined (“unified executive” = loyalty is the only qualification)

– Military weakened (loyalty purges and posturing, alliances attacked, losses of all kinds from the Iran war)

– Infrastructure development neglected (no upgrade plan for antiquated and insecure electrical power, attacking universities instead of strengthening education, nothing for the housing shortage)

– Economy hamstrung (fossil fuels only, ever-changing trade wars, no anti-trust, attacks on contributing foreigners)

– Personal security diminished (pervasive financial insecurity, expensive chaotic healthcare—even measles! Social Security squeezed and threatened)

– Closed mind society (media consolidation and control, xenophobia, overt racism)

– Real catastrophes brewing  (nuclear proliferation, AI, climate change)

 We have an election coming.  We have to hope no amount of money can conceal the enormity of the truth.

 

 

 

The European Heat Wave is Coming for Us

The amazing thing about this title is that it has to be said at all.  There is only one world, and what happens to everyone else on this planet is going to happen to us too.  However the Trump-induced national insanity is such that the European heat wave has made zero impact on the national consciousness.   Those Europeans are just too stupid to understand air conditioning the way we do. We’re too good for climate change.

The Europeans have been hit by climate change that is beyond what their world is equipped to handle.  It  didn’t have to be very many more degrees to have a monumental impact.  This isn’t just a matter of personal discomfort.  Costs of crop failures are monumental, energy costs are way up, wild fires are burning in unheard-of places, and water levels in rivers are so low that they block commerce and cooling for nuclear power plants.  Once nature starts getting out of whack, it hurts everyone. However as the following chart shows, we’re not so far behind.

The results for us will be different, because our national infrastructure is different.  We do have more air conditioning, but we are not equipped for the electricity needs to double at precisely the same time that we need vast new power for data centers—which also need water supplies for cooling.  We have a large and vulnerable agricultural sector and our own potential for wildfires.  We have not been spared because we are smarter. We’ve been lucky enough to get a little more time to prepare, and all we do is pat ourselves on the back.

I have to end by repeating what always needs emphasizing—there is NO NEW NORMAL we can somehow prepare ourselves to handle.  If we don’t address climate change things will just continue getting worse—more and more rapidly.  There is no alternative to action.  By now we have a pretty good idea of what to do, both immediately and going forward.

We need to beat back the giddiness and do the work.

America First

It goes down too easily “America First”.  On the face of it, it’s an obvious goal for anyone running the country.  But in fact that’s not right.  The real objective is the well-being of the country and everyone in it.  “America First” doesn’t say that, and the difference is important.

America First has embedded in it the idea that all our problems are because someone else has put himself first in line.  So it sells you on what the problems are without even pretending to look at what’s true.  And it’s not just a matter for foreign affairs.  Any problem you have becomes someone else keeping you from getting what’s yours.  It’s a slogan of grievance masquerading as a solution. It doesn’t want you to ask questions.  We know who’s evil and we’ll get rid of them. It’s a slogan to hide behind.

Economics can be complicated, but this story doesn’t have to be.  Let’s talk about the good old days that Trump says he is bringing back—the postwar decades of the fifties and sixties.  What made those times happen?  Coming out of World War II we were the most equitable society we had ever been. The difference between CEO’s and working people’s wages was laughable compared with today.  The GI Bill made college affordable.  Government-funded research and development won the war and established the US predominance that remade the world. That model in one form or another also produced the post-war miracles in Japan, China, and Korea.

What’s the message today about how to reestablish that prosperity?  It’s certainly not what worked before.  No major government role in education, infrastructure, and forward-looking research.  No commitment to democracy.  No unions.  The solution is simple: the rich and powerful will make you rich, so you just get rid of anything in their way and all will be golden.  Don’t look at us–it’s other countries and immigrant parasites stealing everything that’s yours.

The one thing you can say for all that is that it has certainly been great for making them richer.  Inequality in America has reached levels far beyond even the “gilded age” of the nineteen century.  There’s a reason why we need a new message about prosperity: they’re so rich they can run the country for themselves. The following chart of net worth values show the magnitude of the change. The recent Big Beautiful Bill also fits that picture well.

Elon Musk is worth a trillion dollars.  Trump has made on the order of 10 billion for himself and his family since the election. But the broader payoff is for the indefinite future–maybe.  After all we’re told the economy is already great, the greatest economy ever.

What about all those people we’re getting rid of?  Is it really all about them?  We were told they were all murderers and rapists, but that’s not who they’re rounding up–productive families who’ve been here decades.  Supposedly that’s still okay, since once we get rid of the immigrants there will be more of the pot for everyone else.  It hasn’t worked that way.  And  there’s a lesson for that also from the good old post-war days.   The war didn’t bring all elements of society together, but it did bring some marginal groups—Jews and Italians for example—into the mainstream.  That didn’t make things worse for the others, it made things better.  Bringing everyone in meant everyone could contribute. 

What matters is to grow the pot for everyone, and that’s actually more true now than ever before.  Most of the pot is being reinvented before our eyes.   We live in a time where winners and losers are decided by companies and technologies coming from nowhere to dominate the world.  We’ve lost the real main message—what works for individuals and our country is full opportunity for everyone. We need the best and brightest from everywhere to help reinvent the future.  But we can’t work at that one, because we’re too busy spending fortunes on ICE. 

Finally we need to get back to the international part—it’s “America First” after all.  To begin with we need to recognize that the rhetoric about the whole world taking advantage of us is manifestly false.  Apple is an example of why.  We import the hardware and sell it in a combined hardware/software product worth far more than the input.  This is hugely profitable but a net negative for the balance of payments.  The rest of the world is not predatory in this transaction—we retain the high margin part, and the hardware is an intermediate product we can’t make without destroying the economics of the deal. (TSMC does make chips here, but only a small, lower-tech part of their output.) The balance of payments calculation is hardware-based and doesn’t capture what we earn from trade-enabled business.  Even adding in the contribution to balance of payments from services misses most of it.  However once you actually try, it’s not hard to show that the Apple example is far from unusual and that our trade relations with the rest of the world are a clear net positive.

It’s possible in  the future that some currently outsourced production comes to the US, but the main driver for such cases will be robotics bringing down production costs. Despite all the rhetoric, there’s no change to this picture that will recreate lots of 1950’s jobs.  If we want to solve the problems of people left behind in the last decades, we need to get past the blinders of “America First”—and follow the money. To really create jobs we’ll need some of those billionaires’ stratospheric profits. So the situation in the end amounts to something like this:

For the international case too there is a lesson from the good old days.  After World War II we put real money into the Marshall Plan for the recovery of Europe.  That money paid itself back in spades with the spectacular growth of GDP in the whole Euro-American zone.  America First would have left us vastly poorer.  The world is different now, but the economic realities are more similar than you might think.

We have to recognize now as we did then that stability has enormous value.  Even today we can see how war hurts. Conflicts are prodigiously expensive, and nuclear proliferation risks even worse.  The only way out is an international system that works for everyone—American gains far more from a system of rules than it does from turning alliances into protection rackets.  We haven’t profited from the freedom to start wars whenever we want.  And American’s freedom to declare climate change a hoax and sabotage climate action will hurt everyone—with ourselves as deniers most of all.

We as a country and as a world have a primary interest in stability and making things work.  There is no golden age to be found in holding everyone hostage—such a world would be less prosperous, and we have no assurance it would be peaceful or that we will always be on top.  Peace and prosperity are the objectives—nothing less.

Choke Points

Everyone talks about choke points. The Strait of Hormuz was always there and occasionally mentioned as a theoretical issue–until we blundered into it. Now people talk about choke points, but still as something around the edges. Hormuz affects others but not so much us.

However choke points aren’t just geographic. Rare earths were and still remain choke points that the Chinese can use any time they want something from us. Even the military can’t function without them. The Chinese figured out those choke points and prepared, while we just trusted our future–a cautionary tale. But that’s just the beginning.

Let’s go back to a chart from our piece on trade:

🏆 Top 10 U.S. Companies by Market Capitalization (2026 estimates)

  1. NVIDIA Corporation – approx. $4.5 trillion (currently world’s largest)
  2. Apple Inc. – ~$4.0 trillion
  3. Alphabet Inc. – ~$3.8 trillion
  4. Microsoft Corporation – ~$3.6 trillion
  5. Amazon.com, Inc. – ~$2.5 trillion
  6. Meta Platforms, Inc. – ~$1.4 trillion
  7. Broadcom Inc. – ~$1.7 trillion
  8. Tesla, Inc. – ~$1.3 trillion
  9. Berkshire Hathaway Inc. – ~$1.0 trillion
  10. JPMorgan Chase & Co. – ~$0.6–0.7 trillion (approximate, rounding into the top decade range)

As noted, the top two companies are 100% dependent on hardware from TSMC in Taiwan. The companies do the design work, and TSMC builds it. For Nvidia that’s everything. For Apple there is some manufacturing in the US, but not the more advanced, product-defining chips. So the two most valuable companies in the US can do nothing without Taiwan. And again that’s just the beginning. It also says that the entire AI infrastructure on which we are basing the future of the country and for which we are investing inconceivable sums of money is close to 100% dependent on hardware from Taiwan. Those Nvidia cards from Taiwan are our supposed key advantage to win the AI race with China!

So Taiwan is a monumental choke point now and for the foreseeable future. It’s not simple for China to use it, but even harder for us to stop them. Xi made very clear to Trump that he was not to get in the way of China’s plans for the future of Taiwan—whatever those might be—and Trump immediately backed off on planned US arms sales. For the record we have also depleted our own munitions in the Iran war. And our behavior toward Cuba is hardly a model of respect for independence of an island 100 miles off the coast.

Where does that leave us? We may continue to strut around as if we still owned the world, but China has the keys. The idea that we can shake down the rest of the world because no one can touch us is patently false. We need an orderly world where we can avoid wars and count on stability of choke points. That doesn’t happen by itself; it requires allies and international norms. Otherwise it’s no longer our world, as we want to think God made it.

The Fight to the Death

We should be explicit about the path we’re on.  We are engaged in a winner-takes-all fight for AI supremacy.  The operative assumption is that whoever wins will rule the world, because that country will control a version of AI so powerful that it can improve itself to be invincible.  Whoever wins will liquidate all opposition, so there can be no challenge to its power.  That’s the story, true or not. We’ve got to win.

There are many consequences to this.  To start with, no effective regulation of AI is possible, because it is impossible to say what constraints on AI development would get in the way of the fight to the death.  In particular some of the most obviously risky issues—such as autonomous military decision making—are the most untouchable. This the worst kind of arms race, where it’s not just a matter of parity.  Only victory is good enough. There are no effective limits to the amount of money it can take.

But even that is just the beginning.  Once you’re in a fight-to-the-death, any form of international cooperation becomes extraneous.  You can’t think too seriously about common interests when everyone is a mortal enemy.  That mindset is all too easy in any case, since common interests are always a hard sell (even for climate change). So we fall back on the world view we now get everyday—whoever has power deserves what he can get. With the Iran war we’ve gone a step farther, asserting that (with the closing of the Strait of Hormuz) we have absolute freedom to inflict damage on the rest of the world whenever we perceive gain for ourselves.

That this view is acceptable without much pushback is a matter of ultimate hubris.  It’s all okay, because we’re going to win.  In fact we’re not actually much interested in how international competition works or what it will really take to win.  We’ve been on top for so long that we’re entitled.  God will make us win.  That’s not an exaggeration of where we are. 

There’s a lot that we don’t know about the end to this story.  The future is never clear.  But there is one thing that is definitely true—we’re stumbling our way into real danger.  The risks are everywhere. For technology we’re certainly not necessarily on top—even today China is a serious competitor—and we’re burning bridges to the future by killing research investments and attacking all foreigners as parasites. Even for AI we’re a long way from the finish line, and it’s unclear whose paths will get there first. More generally we’re in a wildly unstable arms race with many new technologies, proliferating nuclear weapons, and no good way even to know who is ahead. Yet we’re using war as if it’s a regular element of national policy.

The only workable way to forestall conflict is viable common interest.  You don’t have war or countries laid waste if all parties recognize there’s a lot to lose.  (You can still have homicidal maniacs, but shared prosperity helps keep them out.)  The world needs order, starting with recognition that interdependence, economic and otherwise, is not going away.   So we had better fix it.  Start with economic issues—trade, climate change, AI—and then do something about war.  A fight to the death ends with just that, and who knows how many—both here and abroad—could pay.

The Revision of IPCC’s Climate Scenarios

The UN’s international climate group has revised its set of possible climate change scenarios. They eliminated the most damaging scenario, because of progress in sustainable technologies and because details of the scenario itself seemed unlikely to occur. Trump and other climate deniers have seized upon this change to claim it shows all discussion of climate change is bogus. The following piece was done as a comment to an article in the NY Times.

It seems to me one of the problems with this discussion of scenarios is that people want the scenarios to tell them something different than what the scenarios are trying to do. The scenarios are attempts to model different levels of response to the problem of climate change. There is no default case where we do nothing. For that case the only limit to the temperature is the end year in the study—the temperature would just keep increasing.

The main thing that has happened since the original scenarios is that the world has taken some measures that help: costs of wind and solar solutions have come way down to the point that those make up the majority of new electricity generation worldwide. Electric cars have become cheaper, better, and more prevalent. So it’s not surprising that the current view is somewhat more optimistic.

Where that actually leaves us can never be completely clear. I’m willing to bet the models never considered that the most powerful country in the world would be run by someone trying to sabotage the whole effort. Or that data centers would suddenly demand more power than cities. Or that the Iran war would show everyone the risks of imported oil. There will always be reassessments.

This new set of scenarios should make us appreciate the work that has been done. We can make progress against climate change. But there is much that needs to happen and very strong forces against it. This will never be easy, but it needs to be done.

On Top of the Heap

We’ve been there for more than 75 years, since the end of World War II.  We are the power that maintains the world order. As such we’ve overseen a remarkable period of growing global (and our own) prosperity.  People from both political parties agree that we are the ones that make things happen.  We’re so comfortable with that role we’ve come to believe it is ours by right and permanent.

Recently though our attitudes toward that role have changed.  We’ve now decided that since we’re in position to run the world, we ought to be able to keep more of the benefits for ourselves.  So instead of maintaining that world order, we’re now in it for everything we can get—confident that the sky is now the limit.

However we have found there’s a hitch.  We attacked a medium-sized country—Iran–to put them in their place, and we didn’t win.  Not only that, an even more minor power—Ukraine—has shown itself more capable of defending our allies than we are. We still have more bombs and aircraft carriers than anyone else, but somehow that doesn’t do the job anymore.  And the problem is getting worse.  We’ve been so preoccupied with China, we haven’t noticed that the problem is not just that.

With nuclear proliferation, computer-controlled drones, and rapidly evolving AI the past pecking order no longer holds.  Instead the future looks considerably more chaotic—with murky and changing notions of international strength and weakness and risks of conflict from both overconfidence and paranoia.  When we tell everybody our new story—that powerful countries should be able to do anything they want to everybody else (because that’s the way it ought to be)—it not always so clear which side of the story is us.  And lowering the threshold to war isn’t necessarily such a great idea either.

Whether we want to admit it or not, we were pretty stupid in the Iran war.  We ignored obvious issues when we attacked, and we were so overconfident that we didn’t do even the most basic job of preparing for the fight.  We didn’t win.  But that’s not the end of it.  Our changed notion of international roles was equally stupid and blind.  We gave up on the idea of international order just when we actually need it, when we can no longer count on always ruling the roost.

Neither problem has a simple solution.  We’re going to come out of the Iran war worse off than when we started.  It’s hard even to guess what we’ll have to give up.  For the world order things are different.  We have proven that a reasonable world order can benefit everyone (at least generally).  We don’t have to be able to shakedown everyone else.  We just have to participate in recreating and inventing conditions for international success.  That must now include addressing climate change, for example, in addition to preventing war.  The job is not simple but the choice itself is: we can either help to create a livable world or suffer in nuclear-armed chaos.