The Rare Earth affair tells us a very important simple truth:  contrary to the endlessly-repeated Republican message, the unfettered private sector (AKA the “free market”) does NOT solve all problems.  The private sector by itself is not sensitive to national security concerns and isn’t terribly worried about single sourcing so long as the price is right. After all there has never been a problem.  Tough luck.

This isn’t some strange outlier issue—it’s the main story.  The business community serves its own interest and generally with a short-term focus.  No one gets promoted for wasting money on what isn’t going to happen, which includes low probability events and any significantly different futures.  The private sector is good at optimizing its own operation.  It’s not good at providing for the population, the environment, or even the conditions for its own long-term success.  There is no “free market” magic to make that happen.  If the government doesn’t do it, it won’t get done.  And that is terrible for the future of the country.  We’re going to get one Rare Earth problem after another (and not just for security reasons), because we’re making sure not to look out for them.

We should be very clear about what we have today.  Trump wants to run everything, but that doesn’t mean we have government doing its job.  On the contrary what we have is business capture of government, so government is making sure that what business wants and nothing else gets done.  That’s why we can’t have government-sponsored basic research or any consideration of consequences of climate change.  Instead we have a whole bunch of protectionist tariffs and business tax cuts—just what business always wants.  There’s a juicy story of golden futures for everyone, but that comes cheap.  There’s no serious logic behind it, just what businessmen always want to believe.  Trump wants to mess with the business environment, but he hasn’t taken his businessman’s hat off.  He just thinks he’s such a genius he can tell all those big shot execs how to run things. Even the H1B affair fits here—there’s no strategic issue, since those pointy-headed engineers are a dime a dozen.

You don’t have to be a PhD economist to understand this.  Adam Smith understood it in 1776. I won’t give the usual long quote.  We just need a shorter one: “The government of an exclusive company of merchants is, perhaps, the worst of all governments for any country whatever.” — Book IV, Ch. VII