World Order and the EU Model

There are lots of arguments for and against world governance.  The negatives are easy:  there is no enforcement, there are any number of ways to cheat for advantages, rules are always going to reflect the interests of the countries with the power to dictate them.  Any rule gets in the way of our ability to work for our advantage.  What’s more, anything imposed worldwide is a straitjacket—there is no way to hide, no way to escape it.

However historically the opposite of order has been worse:  instability, imperialism, slavery, and war.  The post-World War II period has been far from perfect, but still a record period of prosperity and at least relative peace.  Furthermore we have a specific example of a corner of the world (Europe) that ended centuries of conflict by relinquishing power to an international body—the EU—that brought peace and prosperity (despite all those negatives). Humans have managed to graduate from small tribes to cities to nation states, so why not farther?

Much has been written on that subject, but what is undeniable is that peace and prosperity go together.  Why is it so hard, when we’ve seen examples of success? In fact there’s an answer but only if we ask the question right. The problem with a world order is not that it can’t be made to work—that’s what has been done.  It’s that there are too many forces that want it to fail.

Today’s USA is a case in point.  Trump rose to power with the slogan of “America First”—the idea that all problems were due to immigrants and foreigners taking advantage of us, so untrammeled American power was the highway to everyone’s success.  It was a great story—we know exactly what to do to get rich, and what’s more we can enjoy the pain we inflict on all the bad guys.  So the right vision for international relations is might makes right.  That’s the natural order of things, and of course we’ll win.

Two years later the problems are still around (or worse), billionaires and insiders are collecting benefits, and even the idea that we’re always on top is not so clear. We live in a complicated interconnected world, and however much we bluster about national self-sufficiency, we have no idea how to do it.  “Rare earths” are more the norm than the exception in a world with choke points everywhere.  After all the technological underpinning of a very large chunk of our current and future economy is at TSMC, 80 miles off the coast of China. (Their US production won’t change that.) What’s more the main target of all the tariffs and other economic weapons we’re rolling out is precisely the one country against whom we have essentially no defense! The Democratic successes in the recent election show that some part of the population now realizes the story was always a con, but the issue is how reliably that argument works.

Every nationalist movement tells that same story.   It appeals to something fundamentally tribal in the human makeup:  “My people aren’t like that.”  Get rid of the others, and all will be fine.  Humans may have managed to graduate to nation states, but the tendency to division and conflict remains.  (Thurber’s little storybook (The Last Flower) comes to mind.  “Liberators” as in the picture are the worst.)

So how do we get past this?  What’s different now is that we cannot continue to believe that the rest of the world simply doesn’t matter.  The dangers are worldwide, too pressing, and too great.  Let’s make a list.  I’d put nuclear weapons at the top—we’re encouraging nuclear proliferation at the same time that prohibitions on use of such weapons seem to be weakening in both Ukraine and Iran, and finally as we’ve embarked on new rounds of  an AI-based arms race.  Then there is climate change—where there is still no appreciation of the dangers of waiting, the Covid-demonstrated inadequacy of response to epidemic, and the still unclear consequences of AI itself.  A recent novel set in 2119 delivered a clear verdict on our times: the young people of that future world had no interest in history—why should they care about people whose craven negligence had produced world war and climate catastrophe!

The only way out is to start working on solvable problems.  The EU started with common trade rules for base products: coal and steel.  Economics is the necessary first step.  Trade relations come  before politics.  Unfortunately in this country there is whole false mythology on that subject:  “Bill Clinton let China in the WTO, and that lost 5 million jobs.” Clinton did let China in the WTO, but the President who lost all those jobs was George W. Bush. Bush had no interest in acting against China in the WTO and instead promoted offshoring of jobs, because that was what American business wanted.  Bush even removed buy-American rules for government purchases. Walmart was the smiling US face of “evil China”.  As a recent paper pointed out, the WTO continues to have an important role and is the single first place to start getting international relations right.  Our current tariff policy, by contrast, hurts us and our allies and has weakened our leverage with China to nothing.

Similarly we need to get back into the World Health Organization (where our absence puts us at risk) and we need to return to an active role in international efforts to address climate change.  As it is, our climate denial is bad for its own sake and contributes more to China’s industrial dominance every day (helped on by the Iran war).

None of this is enough to pull the world together to address all the dangers, but these activities are doable and start to address what it means to work together.  That’s what worked for the EU.  Anything more is beyond the scope of this piece.  But the dangers of nationalist divisions and conflict remain.  For that there are no silver bullets.  The best hope is progress toward global prosperity—which remains, despite all slogans to the contrary, in the interest of all.

Who Gets the Winning?

OUTCOMES OF THE BIG BEAUTIFUL BILL ACT AND 2025 TARIFFS

Income DecileAvg IncomeTax CutTariff CostService Cuts
(Medicaid, SNAP)
NET RESULT% of Total Benefits
1 (poorest)$38,843+$150-$650-$1,200-$2,7000% (net loss)
2$62,457+$300-$700-$1,000-$1,4000% (net loss)
3$75,733+$500-$800-$600-$9000% (net loss)
4$89,522+$800-$900-$400-$5000% (net loss)
5 (median)$105,481+$1,200-$1,000-$400-$2000% (net loss)
6$122,119+$1,500-$1,100-$300+$100<1% (break even)
7$143,667+$2,000-$1,300-$500+$2001.8%
8$171,786+$2,500-$1,500-$200+$8007.0%
9$218,026+$4,500-$2,000-$0+$2,50021.9%
10 (richest)$517,699+$14,700-$3,400+$0+$7,90069.3%

Source: Yale Budget Lab combined analysis of Big Beautiful Bill Act + 2025 tariffs

Note: Within the top 10%, the richest 1% alone captures 43.9% of all benefits – nearly half of everything.


The Bigger Story from Rare Earths

The Rare Earth affair tells us a very important simple truth:  contrary to the endlessly-repeated Republican message, the unfettered private sector (AKA the “free market”) does NOT solve all problems.  The private sector by itself is not sensitive to national security concerns and isn’t terribly worried about single sourcing so long as the price is right. After all there has never been a problem.  Tough luck.

This isn’t some strange outlier issue—it’s the main story.  The business community serves its own interest and generally with a short-term focus.  No one gets promoted for wasting money on what isn’t going to happen, which includes low probability events and any significantly different futures.  The private sector is good at optimizing its own operation.  It’s not good at providing for the population, the environment, or even the conditions for its own long-term success.  There is no “free market” magic to make that happen.  If the government doesn’t do it, it won’t get done.  And that is terrible for the future of the country.  We’re going to get one Rare Earth problem after another (and not just for security reasons), because we’re making sure not to look out for them.

We should be very clear about what we have today.  Trump wants to run everything, but that doesn’t mean we have government doing its job.  On the contrary what we have is business capture of government, so government is making sure that what business wants and nothing else gets done.  That’s why we can’t have government-sponsored basic research, professionalism in government, or any consideration of consequences of climate change.  Instead we have a whole bunch of protectionist tariffs and business tax cuts—just what business always wants.  There’s a juicy story of golden futures for everyone, but that comes cheap.  There’s no serious logic behind it, just what businessmen always want to believe.  Trump wants to mess with the business environment, but he hasn’t taken his businessman’s hat off.  He just thinks he’s such a genius he can tell all those big shot execs how to run things. Even the H1B affair fits here—there’s no strategic issue, since those pointy-headed engineers are a dime a dozen.

You don’t have to be a PhD economist to understand this.  Adam Smith understood it in 1776. I won’t give the usual long quote.  We just need a shorter one: “The government of an exclusive company of merchants is, perhaps, the worst of all governments for any country whatever.” — Wealth of Nations, Book IV, Ch. VII

Trump’s Tariffs are a Dry Run for the World’s Future

As the Trump administration ramps up its efforts to sabotage climate action, we have to think about what that means.  There is only one atmosphere, and the consequences of climate change are becoming ever more obvious.  Our policies are not just putting the US at risk, we’re putting everyone at risk.

So it is only a matter of time before the rest of the world will have to react.  The US has become not just a rogue state but a criminally insane one.  The only reasonable action is a global embargo.  The US has to be treated as a matter for quarantine.

Fortunately for the rest of the world, Trump is providing an excellent transitional strategy.  As exports to the US become subject to draconian and unpredictable risks, the world has a chance to live without us. The supposed lifeline we’re throwing to the rest of the world is actually worthless—building factories in the US just increases the exposure to Trump’s whims, and further the fossil-fuel-privileged industries of the US (e.g. cars) will have little future elsewhere.

There is a remarkable consistency in US policy—we are doing everything we can to turn ourselves from a world power into an afterthought.  That’s not just the tariffs, it’s the attacks on education, healthcare, and forward-looking research.  The demonizing of all immigrants. It’s amazing what dreams of past imperial greatness can do.

Maybe it’s in part an Anglo-Saxon thing.  The parallels with Britain are close, although our fall is much greater.  Brexit was Britain’s effort to restore its nineteenth century dominance by withdrawing from cooperation with the EU.  The result was an instantaneous economic downturn that took about five years for the population to understand.  There may well be no way back—with more Farage populism in the offing, the downward spiral could continue.

We voted for Trump to bring back the glories of the post-war fifties.  He has promised to make everyone rich by shaking down the rest of the world.  With tariffs, we are in essence doing our own Brexit with everyone else. Whatever the evangelicals may believe, there is no God protecting us from folly.